Riddle #16 – Who Is Lying?

Three different doctors said that Paul is their brother

yet Paul claims he has no brothers.

Who is lying?


And while you’re here, check out these 10 facts about Lying…

Definition: Lying involves making a false statement with the intention to deceive. It’s distinct from simply being mistaken or remembering incorrectly, as the speaker must knowingly present false information.

Developmental Milestone: Children typically begin to lie between the ages of 2 and 5. This can actually be a developmental milestone, indicating that a child understands the difference between reality and falsehood, and can anticipate others’ reactions.

Types of Lies: There are several types of lies, including white lies, which are often considered harmless and may be told to avoid hurting someone’s feelings; blatant lies, which are outright untruths; and lies of omission, where information is left out to deceive.

Polygraph Tests: Polygraph tests, also known as lie detector tests, measure physiological responses such as heart rate, blood pressure, and respiratory rate to determine if someone is lying. However, their reliability is widely debated, and they are not admissible as evidence in many courts.

Microexpressions: Microexpressions are involuntary facial expressions that can betray what a person is really feeling, potentially indicating deceit. However, accurately reading microexpressions requires training and is not foolproof.

Neuroscience of Lying: Neuroimaging studies have shown that lying activates the prefrontal cortex, the area of the brain involved in decision making, suggesting that lying involves suppressing the truth and formulating a false statement.

Dishonesty and Stress: Lying can cause stress and anxiety, as it often leads to a fear of being caught. This stress can sometimes be detected through non-verbal cues such as fidgeting or changes in voice pitch.

Plausible Deniability: People sometimes craft their lies to maintain plausible deniability, leaving enough ambiguity so that if they are caught, they can claim that they were misunderstood or misinterpreted.

Kantian Ethics on Lying: The philosopher Immanuel Kant argued that lying is always morally wrong, even white lies. According to his Categorical Imperative, we should act only according to maxims that we would be willing to have as universal laws, and if everyone lied, trust and communication would break down.
Potential Benefits of Lying: While generally considered morally wrong, lying can sometimes have benefits, such as protecting someone’s feelings, maintaining social bonds, or protecting oneself or others from harm. Ethical debates continue around when, if ever, lying might be justified.

Fancy trying some even harder riddles? Click here for many more!


Share this!